Modern Oil

Debunking the Myth of the Oil Crisis

The opening years of the 21st century are marked by milestones in the world of oil: the war in Iraq, the Shell reserves downgrade, Hurricane Katrina, and the breaking of the once unthinkable $100 per barrel barrier. Many have seized on these events as evidence that we are crossing the threshold of ‘peak oil’. Behind us, a century and a half of abundant, cheap oil that fuelled industrial civilization and brought unparalleled prosperity to a fortunate global minority. Ahead of us, permanent declines in oil production, scarce and unaffordable energy, wars over dwindling resources, disastrous climate change, perhaps the collapse of modern society. But these ideas are based on misconceptions, flawed reasoning, and excessive pessimism. The world has abundant oil and gas for decades to come, geopolitical conflicts can be avoided by adroit policies, and we can learn to use hydrocarbons without unacceptable environmental damage.

We have been here before. In 1865, the economist William Jevons warned that Britain’s global supremacy would shortly be ended by the exhaustion of its coal mines. The pioneering conservationist Gifford Pinchot wrote in 1910 that “our supplies of iron ore, mineral oil and natural gas are being rapidly depleted, and many of the great fields are already exhausted”. There were further predictions of imminent oil decline from industry geologists in 1885, 1919 and 1956, from Jimmy Carter in 1977, from the US government in 1980. A prominent ‘peak oiler’, Colin Campbell, claimed in 1989 that oil output had peaked; another, Kenneth Deffeyes, put the peak date, rather precisely, at December 16th 2005.

The current high prices certainly seem to give some credibility to the idea that we are approaching some fundamental limit of oil resources. But we should remember how we arrived at this situation, since the culprit is not constraints on oil in the ground: it is the long 1986-98 period of low prices and under-investment. Low prices decimated the oil industry, while the rise of energy-hungry new powers in Asia, combined with robust demand in the developed world and geopolitical upsets in major producers, stealthily ate up spare production capacity. The inevitable result, perhaps amplified by ‘speculation’ and market nervousness, has been a so-far inexorable rise in the oil price.

This price rise is not driven, then, primarily by geology. But many commentators outside the energy business, and some within it, believe high oil prices vindicate their often-repeated claims that ‘peak oil’ is imminent. Supporters of this view point to the work of the American geologist M. King Hubbert, whose seminal 1956 paper prophesied a peak in US output by 1965-1970 (the actual year was 1970), a success often taken to prove that oil depletion must follow ‘Hubbert’s Curve’. Yet when applied to other countries, ‘Hubbert’s Curve’ and its variants are at best approximately right, but frequently wildly wrong.

Predictions of the date of ‘peak oil’ require some estimate of the amount of oil reserves known today, and the quantity to be found in the future. Believers in imminent depletion state that global reserves, particularly in the OPEC countries, are heavily over-stated, that exploration success is falling well short of replacing production, and that technology does not unlock significant new oil. These assumptions imply that we are on the cusp of producing half of our ultimate total of oil. Hubbert’s method therefore predicts imminent decline.

Although a few countries may be over-estimating their reserves, comprehensive industry databases suggest that, if anything, the aggregate official figures are somewhat low. OPEC’s upgrades in the mid-1980s are mostly reasonable given prior conservatism, exploration success and advances in technology. Lack of recent exploration success is due to limited effort during the low-price era, and to restrictions on access to promising areas like major OPEC countries, Russia and the US offshore. In any case, huge recent discoveries in areas like deepwater Brazil confound the pessimists. ‘Reserves growth’ is a real and major phenomenon in many major oil regions, not an artefact of conservative reporting — the best place to look for new oil is in oil fields, with fresh ideas and methods.

‘Unconventional’ oil is becoming conventional, and making up a growing proportion of supply. Output from the famous ‘oil sands’ of Canada is growing rapidly; heavy oil all around the world is attracting new attention, from the UK to Russia to Saudi Arabia to Congo. Liquid fuels can be made from abundant coal and gas. ‘Second generation’ biofuels, from non-food crops, promise to overcome the problems of rising food prices, while the trillions of barrels in oil shales may be on the verge of being unlocked. And a wide swathe of oil demand can be substituted by abundant natural gas, which, even more than oil, is nowhere near ‘peak’, and which emits much less carbon dioxide.

Nor is geopolitics the insuperable threat it is made out to be. The abundance and geographic dispersal of unconventional oil and other energy sources renders a long-term oil embargo self-destructive. Nor is the Middle East rabidly hostile to the West and keen to wield the ‘oil weapon’, despite xenophobic claims. Modern ‘resource wars’ cannot pay for themselves, as the Iran-Iraq war and the recent Iraqconflict amply demonstrate. Terrorism is not capable of disrupting the long-term energy picture — as long as it does not provoke its victims into ill-conceived retaliation. The military, practical and political difficulties of blocking the ‘choke-points’ of international oil trade are widely under-estimated. ‘Energy independence’ cannot be attained at acceptable cost by any large consuming or producing nation. Retreats into paranoid self-sufficiency threaten a re-run of the grim 1930s; energy security can only be achieved, or at least improved, by a balance between the needs of exporters and importers, and a web of mutual inter-dependency.

Even the serious environmental problems associated with fossil fuel extraction and use, particularly some unconventional sources, can be tackled by new technologies, incentivised by policies to make the ‘polluter pay’. The environmental impact of modern oil extraction, even in sensitive areas such as offshore or in the Arctic, is much less than generally imagined. The very real threat of climate change requires a portfolio of solutions. A key one is ‘carbon sequestration’, the locking away of carbon dioxide in underground reservoirs, a method that can also liberate additional oil and gas. Despite claims to the contrary, all the components of carbon sequestration are proven; they need only to be put together on a large, repeatable scale.

Energy efficiency and renewable energy are key components of the fight against both climate change and the phantom of oil depletion. A growing economy and living standards would be possible even in the face of declining oil use. ‘Neo-Luddite’ calls for the end of industrial civilization are, if taken seriously, both naïve and apocalyptic. In this sense, oil will never ‘run out’; it will be replaced by something better. That is the best and most positive reply to Jevons’ fears about the ‘end of coal’, and to the modern peak oil movement.

©2008 Robin M. Mills

 

About the Author

Robin M. Mills is an oil industry professional with a background in both geology and economics. Currently, he is Senior Evaluation Manager for Dubai Energy. Previously, he worked for Shell. Mills is a member of the International Association for Energy Economics and Association of International Petroleum Negotiators. He holds a Master’s Degree in Geological Sciences from Cambridge University. His book, The Myth of the Oil Crisis: Overcoming the Challenges of Depletion, Geopolitics, and Global Warning, is available August 2008 from Praeger Publishers.

http://www.praeger.com/catalog/B36498.aspx

ISBN: 0-313-36498-2
ISBN-13: 978-0-313-36498-3

History Channel – Oil Spill Bioremediation on Modern Marvels

Chef’s Planet Glass Cruets $14.95 Serve fine oil and vinegar in these crystal-clear oil & vinegar cruets for elegant presentation on the table. Beautifully balanced and truly dripless with streamlined stopper to control the flow and curved spout for spillproof pouring. Innovative collar catches overflow to preserve linens or table surfaces. These glass cruets allow perfect drizzling onto salads, vegetables, risottos or breads. Sup…

Rachael Ray Stoneware EVOO Oil Dispensing Bottle, Purple $14.17 The Rachael Ray EVOO Dispensing Bottle is uniquely designed for storing and keeping close at hand extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) for cooking and finishing dishes. Spice up a meal by drizzling your favorite olive oil over a fine pasta dish or simply dab on a crostini to make a tasty little Tuscan treat. A perfect complement to any meal. Features: This 24-oz. cruet is perfect for EVOO, extra virgin o…

Rachael Ray Stoneware 2-Piece EVOO Oil and Vinegar Bottle Set, Purple $29.95 The Rachael Ray EVOO Dispensing Bottle is uniquely designed for storing and keeping close at hand extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) for cooking and finishing dishes. Spice up a meal by drizzling your favorite olive oil over a fine pasta dish or simply dab on a crostini to make a tasty little Tuscan treat. A perfect complement to any meal. Features: These 24-oz. and 13-oz. cruets are perfect for EVOO, …

Don Gillis: Symphonies No. 3 & 10; Tulsa $12.93 ###############################################################################################################################################################################################################################################################…

James LAWLESS & The RatBastard Orchestra – Oil Castles on the Gulf Coast $12.00 The third in the trilogy of Modern/Classical Chamber Music for Yound people with Fresh Minds. All profits from the Solid or Digital formats of this Disc go to Gulf Coast Animal Rescue Charities due to the Deepwater Horizon Tragedy.Go Fast! Yer Mom’s Comin’!Synthphoneya Moderne #28 (movement 1 thru 4)Synthphoneya Moderne #28 (movement 5 thru 7)The Ups & Downs of Deep Water DrillingPurely Autonomous…

Vital Organs $6.99 …

Modern Marvels: Alaskan Oil Pipeline [VHS] $8.00 ” It is a story of man’s struggle with nature, but also of a battle to protect nature from man. It is a tale of engineering genius and the brutal labor of thousands of men. The Trans-Alaska Pipeline opened in 1977, carrying crude oil from Prudhoe Bay to Prince William Sound, a distance of 800 miles. It is one of the most important and impressive engineering projects of the modern age. ALASK…

Modern Marvels: Offshore Oil Drilling [VHS] $24.95 …

Oil Fire Fighting (Modern Marvels) $3.69 They are visions worthy of hell–pillars of flame that can explode hundreds of feet in the air and burn for weeks or more. They are oil well fires, and the men who put them out have one of the most dangerous jobs on earth. MODERN MARVELS heads into the flames to see how the conflagrations are contained and controlled. From the use of explosives to the exploits of pioneers like Myron Kinley, OIL FI…

Moen DN6724ORB Danbury 24-Inch Towel Bar, Oil Rubbed Bronze $18.49 Moen DN6724ORB Oil rubbed bronze 24″ towel bar oil rubbed bronze finish delivers a rich, dark brown, old world finish with striking light and dark accents limited lifetime warranty…